A Case For Black & White Photography

Posted on


Figure 3. A straight print of the original negative (left) versus the final “visualized” print (right) after increasing contrast and darkening the sky.
In making the image, I had felt a deep impression of a dark brooding storm with heavy sky and vibrant hanging clouds. When I got home and made my first print, I wound up increasing the contrast in the foreground clouds and forest, and darkened the sky to achieve the mood I had felt for the image (Figure 3). Success!

Upshot: A black-and-white image, being already an abstract of reality, can render a scene with considerable drama or delicate nuance, without looking forced or “wrong.” The photographer is in charge of his or her own reality.

Making A Black-And-White Image

Following are a few tips for getting the best shot, whether shooting digital or analog. The principles of photography are largely the same with film and digital, though the particulars of achieving a desired vision in black and white with the different platforms require some unique techniques. When I am contemplating making an exposure, I tend to think of things in the following order:

Composition. What is it that attracted me to the scene or subject in the first place? Where is the best place for my lens? My relative position to the subject(s) establishes the structure of the image. If I move a bit to the left, does a tree branch start to get in the way? If I lower my eye, does a fence post start to bump into the prime object of my image? I have made some images where the difference of an inch or two in lens position could make or break a composition.

All of this is done before I ever get my camera out, and I frequently use a framing card or my hands to “audition” my composition. Quoting Mark Twain in his essay Fenimore Cooper’s Literary Offenses: “Eschew surplussage!” If it’s not needed in the image, don’t include it. Or at least minimalize it.

Lens choice. The only thing a change in focal length really does is change the cropping of your image. Choose your spot, then choose the focal length that gives the best cropping. Choice of lens has no effect on the subject structure of an image — that is governed by the location of the lens relative to the subject(s). What is often attributed to “lens compression” is actually a result of changing lens location to suit a long focal-length lens. If the camera position is not moved, the relationship of elements in a scene remains unchanged regardless of focal length.

Filter choice. If you are working digitally, most filter effects can be done in post-processing, as explained above. The exceptions are in using neutral density (ND) filters to extend exposure time, and polarizers to darken skies or control reflections. A “1A Skylight” filter can cut through haze nicely. With black-and-white film or a Leica Monochrom, which captures in black and white only, a colored filter has to be decided on before exposure.

Rocks and Mist, Otter Cove, Big Sur, 1980. I left Ansel’s full-time employ in mid-1979 to open my own advertising studio in San Francisco. During my five-year tenure in Carmel, I had slowly become so accustomed to the wonderful surroundings that I found myself photographing in the area less and less, to the point where I hardly got my cameras out at all. (A few years ago, I wrote a blog post on the subject, titled “Too Close to Home.”) As irony would have it, one of my early assignments was to do a series of seascape posters for the newly named Seagate Technology. There were to be four black-and-white posters, and the only requirement was that they be vertical, shot on 8×10 film, and be made in the Santa Cruz-to-Big Sur area. I drove down to Carmel Highlands, stopped by to say hi to Adams, and headed down to Big Sur. I stopped at a spot I had zoomed past for the previous five years, set up and made another of my favorite images. It was the first poster—and barely a mile south of Adams’ house.

With digital, it is possible to see the effect of black and white right away. While I tend to capture only in RAW mode, if you set your camera to capture in both RAW and JPEG with a monochrome setting, most cameras will render the JPEG as a black-and-white image. If you want to preview the effect of a filter, you can put an actual filter in front of the lens, and the image review will show that color effect.

Exposure. With digital, the crucial approach is to not over-expose highlights. If the sensors are overloaded, there is very little, or nothing, to recover in post-processing. A washed-out white cloud is much harder to live with than empty shadows — and deep shadows can often be recovered to a surprising degree.

The histogram will also tell you immediately whether you have held your highlights. If the histogram is slammed into the right side of its window, reduce your exposure and do another capture. Hopefully your subject is still there for a second try.

With film, the opposite approach is the rule. The one thing that cannot be fixed after the fact is under exposure. It takes a scientific amount of light to rattle the silver molecules enough for there to be anything to develop. If the film does not get that minimum amount of light, there is nothing to print or scan, just clear film.

Sandstorm, White Spray, Great Sand Dunes, Colorado, 1997. A few years after relocating my business and family to Santa Fe, New Mexico, I got a call from an art director at a New York ad agency asking if I had any stock images of sandstorms. I replied that I wasn’t generally inclined to subject my equipment to such conditions, and the reply was, “Gee, well, maybe we can make it worth you looking in to it.” I decided to accept the challenge and set off to see if I could find a sandstorm. Being in Santa Fe, I was only a few hours from Great Sand Dunes National Park to the north and White Sands National Monument to the south. I made several trips to both with no luck. I tried Great Sand Dunes one more time and hit pay-dirt, er … sand. I used my Mamiya RZ67 camera, as it would be pure folly to try using a large-format camera. I cut a hole in the corner of a large clear plastic bag and taped the opening tightly around the front of the lens barrel, and put a Wratten #25 red filter over the lens to darken the sky and shaded sand. The wind was so fierce, I had to use a relatively fast shutter speed, and thus couldn’t use a very small aperture. With blowing sand and little depth-of-field, I knew nothing could really be very sharp, so had to rely on strong composition and tonality to carry the day. The agency loved the shot, and I was picking sand out of my ears for days. And I can still see where the legs of my tripod had been set—sandblasted!

Is black-and white photography for you? Only you can answer that. There are countless, stunning color images that would be a complete bore in black and white. If National Geographic or NASA worked only in black and white, there would be so much in and out of this world we would know nothing about. If flowers and fall colors were only shown in shades of gray, how dreary! I photograph to express my feelings about things I see. I do photograph a lot in color, but it is the black-and-whites that let me express a reality in a very personal way.


Prev5 of 5Next

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *